AFI Top 100: Mr. Smith Goes to Washington (1939)

The sixth in a series reviewing the American Film Institute Top 100 in random order.

“The people of my state need permanent relief from crooked men riding their backs!” – James Stewart as Senator Jefferson Smith

 

There’s a great scene early on in Mr. Smith Goes to Washington where our naive, newly appointed Senator realizes that several newspaper writers have printed out-of-context pictures of him in his first few days in town, ascribing views to him he does not hold. There follows a montage of him storming the streets of DC, looking menacing and punching the offenders in their faces. It’s meant to be cathartic, and Dimitri Tiomkin‘s swirling, whimsical score that plays over the scene reinforces that we should vicariously enjoy Smith’s righteous anger. It was a scene that would be echoed decades later at the end of Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back (this time accompanied by Stroke 9′s ‘Kick Some Ass’), with one important piece missing. Jeff Smith eventually gets called down by members of the National Press Club who inform him, in no uncertain terms, that he is in fact a joke, a ceremonial appointment whose only purpose is serve out the two months left on his predecessor’s term and not make waves. It’s the first moment when the doe-eyed Smith realizes that not everything he’d been taught about how the government works was on the up and up. Throughout the rest of the film, he comes face to face with how corrupt the system really is, how biased lawmaking is toward wealthy contributors, and how little power our elected officials wield when they have to choose between getting reelected and following their consciences.

It was difficult watching this film, almost three-quarters of a century after its release, and realizing that so little has changed for the better. In fact, it seems as if things are much worse than they were back then. Once Smith realizes that graft is such a big problem in his state, he launches into a Quixotic crusade to try to fix the situation. He’s helped along the way by his lovely and politically astute secretary, Clarissa Saunders (Jean Arthur), and together, they devise a way to foil his home state’s political machine and expose the corrupting influences for who they really are. It involves a marathon filibuster session, wherein all Smith has to do to keep the kickback-laden bill from passing is to keep talking, not yield the floor, and not sit down. It’s really quite up-lifting.

Until, that is, you realize that few if any of our elected officials would give enough of a damn to mount such a fight even if they were so inclined to today. For crying out loud, nobody even has to filibuster in the Senate anymore. All one has to do is announce one’s intent to filibuster, and the questionable legislation is tabled. No one seems to have the time to do the actual legislating we’ve sent them to Washington to do. Last year, Sen Dick Durbin told NPR’s Planet Money podcast, that the average Senator was spending three to four hours every day working the phone banks like a telemarketer, raising money for his or her next reelection campaign. Considering that’s what it takes to even keep one’s seat at the table, it’s no wonder Congress has passed fewer than twenty laws so far this year. Who’s got the time when re-election campaigns start from Day One…?

Horrible.

 

Up next in the queue, 1940′s The Philadelphia Story, in which our hero hopes to learn that back in the day, rom-coms had a more believable romances and funnier jokes. 

Click here for an Index of my AFI Top 100 movie reviews.

72 comments on “AFI Top 100: Mr. Smith Goes to Washington (1939)

  1. Susana says:

    Joe is an self important atneotitn whore.He got a buzz off of the idea that he might be more powerful than the pres because he felt as though he was the deciding factor. I wondered how long it would take him to realize he wasn’t the only game in town and with all of the atneotitn Snowe is getting how long it would be before he threw a temper tantrum.Being the self important atneotitn whore that he is it didn’t take very long. I suspect he has been stomping his little feet for awhile now demanding his cut of the importance, flailing on the floor like a child at the market when no one pays atneotitn to his demand for atneotitn. We all know someone needs to pick him up and give him a nice swat in the ass, yet no one does.I don’t believe anyone threatened his standing in committee but I believe it is more likely Joe got offered something more than he already has.And the really sad part is, whatever he was offered won’t do a damn thing for the people Joe represents because it is NOT about them.. it’s all about ego Joe and what he can get personally. ONE good thing came out of the circus that was bush. vs. Gore .we didn’t get stuck with Joe as our vp..I shutter to think how close he was to holding that office and I think America would be better of hunting with cheney than having joe as a vp.

  2. website says:

    Big help, big help. And superlative news of course.

  3. Please teach the rest of these internet hooligans how to write and research!

  4. Unbelievable how well-written and informative this was.

  5. People normally pay me for this and you are giving it away!

  6. God help me, I put aside a whole afternoon to figure this out.

  7. Grazi for making it nice and EZ.

  8. Great stuff, you helped me out so much!

  9. I was looking everywhere and this popped up like nothing!

  10. Taking the overview, this post is first class

  11. AFAIC that’s the best answer so far!

  12. Umm, are you really just giving this info out for nothing?

  13. propecia says:

    Ah, i see. Well that’s not too tricky at all!”

  14. Wowza, problem solved like it never happened.

  15. I think you’ve just captured the answer perfectly

  16. God, I feel like I should be takin notes! Great work

  17. viagra pills says:

    A bit surprised it seems to simple and yet useful.

  18. viagra sales says:

    I was seriously at DefCon 5 until I saw this post.

  19. That’s not just logic. That’s really sensible.

  20. Extremely helpful article, please write more.

  21. mobile says:

    Now I feel stupid. That’s cleared it up for me

  22. So true. Honesty and everything recognized.

  23. That’s a crackerjack answer to an interesting question

  24. It’s really great that people are sharing this information.

  25. Pin my tail and call me a donkey, that really helped.

  26. link says:

    I never thought I would find such an everyday topic so enthralling!

  27. Grazi for making it nice and EZ.

  28. viarga says:

    Hey, that’s the greatest! So with ll this brain power AWHFY?

  29. Very valid, pithy, succinct, and on point. WD.

  30. Great article but it didn’t have everything-I didn’t find the kitchen sink!

  31. click here says:

    Your website has to be the electronic Swiss army knife for this topic.

  32. That’s a slick answer to a challenging question

  33. That’s a well-thought-out answer to a challenging question

  34. My problem was a wall until I read this, then I smashed it.

  35. If not for your writing this topic could be very convoluted and oblique.

  36. Thanks for sharing. Your post is a useful contribution.

  37. And I was just wondering about that too!

  38. Yours is a clever way of thinking about it.

  39. link says:

    There’s a secret about your post. ICTYBTIHTKY

  40. sildenafil says:

    Never would have thunk I would find this so indispensable.

  41. Your post has moved the debate forward. Thanks for sharing!

  42. You really found a way to make this whole process easier.

  43. I’m not quite sure how to say this; you made it extremely easy for me!

  44. Pleasing to find someone who can think like that

  45. Hey, subtle must be your middle name. Great post!

  46. Appreciation for this information is over 9000-thank you!

  47. hair grwoth says:

    A little rationality lifts the quality of the debate here. Thanks for contributing!

  48. I think you hit a bullseye there fellas!

  49. Normally I’m against killing but this article slaughtered my ignorance.

  50. You are so awesome for helping me solve this mystery.

  51. AKAIK you’ve got the answer in one!

  52. A minute saved is a minute earned, and this saved hours!

  53. That’s a brilliant answer to an interesting question

  54. bill monthly says:

    You’re the greatest! JMHO

  55. Super informative writing; keep it up.

  56. help either says:

    That’s a sensible answer to a challenging question

  57. If you want to get read, this is how you should write.

  58. Check that off the list of things I was confused about.

  59. Thanks for your thoughts. It’s helped me a lot.

  60. Call me wind because I am absolutely blown away.

  61. It’s great to find someone so on the ball

  62. That’s an intelligent answer to a difficult question xxx

  63. intangibles says:

    Great article but it didn’t have everything-I didn’t find the kitchen sink!

  64. Thanks for sharing. Your post is a useful contribution.

  65. Holy Toledo, so glad I clicked on this site first!

  66. brain during says:

    Smart thinking – a clever way of looking at it.

  67. Cheers pal. I do appreciate the writing.

  68. deal like says:

    Articles like these put the consumer in the driver seat-very important.

  69. That addresses several of my concerns actually.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>